And then A History of Violence happened, and unlike
most Cronenberg before, the story is mostly just
that, a history. The now of the film managed
somehow to discovery subtly, be calm, and be
hysterically brutal in it's suspense. Because
so little was happening during the film, it became
that much more mind-blowing and painful.... because
in that calm, anything could happen.
Eastern Promises finds Mr. Cronenberg in a similar
mood again, but not quite willing to repeat himself.
He gives us a world that exists for as long as it
can entirely in the gray of existence, good and bad
being about as discernible as red and mauve in the
dark. We accept some characters as bad and
some as good, and then spend the next hour or so
constantly changing our minds, not in major
revelatory ways, but in sort of uncomfortable way
that makes us question our own convictions.
Viggo Mortenson, so well suited to Cronenberg's new
tendencies, places the lead with such brilliance
that we forget he's anything but the driver he
claims to be for most of the movie. He is
dynamic in the dark, intriguing behind the scenes
and powerful when simply smoking. Bouncing off
the violence of Vincent Cassel's character's
inexperience and, really, terror at his place in
life, Mortenson becomes a character we can't help
but be drawn to, even though he's doing things we
really shouldn't want to condone. To have his
opposite in Naomi Watts, an acting force all her
own, is another brilliant moment by Cronenberg
allowing her to be the innocence and goodness that
we wish Mortenson's character could have, but allow
her her own shadows to compliment his. Both
actors, as a result, compliment each other into
another, troubling and wonderful shade of gray for
the film.
And then Cronenberg begins
the beating. Still subtle like he now enjoys
flirting with, but things start to matter, start to
hurt just a little and the audience finds it must
make a decision, settle into a point of view before
things start breaking. And, unlike some other
modern directors, Cronenberg realizes that what some
people would consider a twist is really just
another bit of knowledge that maybe doesn't really
change all that much.
Yet the
explosive moments of Eastern Promises also manage to
occur in a quiet part of the universe, with no pomp
or circumstance, just with all the importance of
reality.
And perhaps that is what
Cronenberg has decided is the most frightening thing
in the universe, reality. So that is what he
gives us, a world like ours where most people are
usually desperate and unsure, nothing is truly black
and white and the feeling of being naked, not
without clothing but, true to the definition,
without protection makes us feel naked, without
clothing, being salivated over by wolves.
The fight scene that has gotten so many talking is
the most realistic and un-glossified (if might make
up a word) fight scene I've seen in a mainstream
movie (if a Cronenberg joint can ever be considered
"mainstream") perhaps ever. It's raw like a
slab of meat which is how the characters getting
hurt are hurt, like slabs of meat. They fight
like men trying to live, not impress, be cool or
anything else a Hollywood character tends to fight
like. Just to keep living, which is really
what the movie is about for every character and, in
the end, why they all remain so hard to judge.
In Eastern Promises everyone is just fighting to try
and keep being alive. If the film is brutal it
is brutal like life. If the film is shocking,
it is shocking like life. And the if the film
is quiet, it's quiet like life... in a very, very
terrible way.